AvMA 2019: Women in law talk ATE

26th June 2019

This year marks the centenary of the Sex Disqualification (Removal) Act 1919 that paved the way for women to enter into the legal profession.

With this in mind, and with this week’s AvMA Annual Clinical Negligence Conference (ACNC) almost upon us, we thought we’d get some female perspectives on ATE insurance and the role it plays in supporting access to justice.

Linda Millband

Linda Millband


National Head of Clinical Negligence and AvMA Panel Member

Fran Clothier

Fran Clothier

DAS UK Group

Business Partnership Manager

1) How important is ATE insurance in 2019?

Linda Millband: “It’s incredibly important for clinical negligence cases. Without it we would not be able to fund the medical reports required to assess whether a case has reasonable prospects of success. And crucially, if the report is unsupportive, the cost of the premium is written off. This allows us to work on a ‘no win, no fee’ basis – the most important factor in respect of the client’s funding.”

Every partner firm is different and every client is different – imposing a ‘one size fits all’ approach just doesn’t work.

Fran Clothier

Fran Clothier: “ATE insurance is a vital part of the overall funding package offered to injured claimants, for the majority of whom the costs risk of proceeding uninsured would be too high, leaving them with no option for recourse.”

2) What is the ATE market doing right?

LM: “The ATE market is contracting and some of the big players have gone into liquidation, seemingly where they tried to cut premiums too much. Although competitive pricing is important, it has become obvious, since LASPO, that if insurers try to reduce premiums too much, their business model will not be viable.

“The providers still in the market are getting it right by providing a better product, at a higher price – a sustainable model.”

FC: “It continues to provide essential access to justice for claimants. Despite an ever-changing market, the best insurers have kept abreast of the changes and responded with propositions that meet the evolving needs of solicitors and their clients. With the introduction of the MOJ portal, LASPO, and now The Civil Liabilities Act approaching, this has been no mean feat!”

3) What could it do better?

LM: “There could be more transparency on how the premiums are calculated so that everyone, including the defendants, could understand this element. This might result in fewer premium disputes upon detailed assessment.”

ATE is incredibly important for clinical negligence cases. Without it we would not be able to fund the medical reports required to assess whether a case has reasonable prospects of success.

Linda Millband

FC: “Something I have learnt to appreciate during my 14 years at DAS is that every partner firm is different and every client is different – imposing a ‘one size fits all’ approach just doesn’t work.

“Insurers must understand firms better and work with them closely to really access the benefits that a strategic, cohesive partnership can offer. A market-leading ATE insurer will also be curious about all areas of the law and consider how ATE can help more people get access to justice.

“There is also potential to be unlocked by embracing a more creative approach with a view to expanding the areas of law considered viable for ATE insurance.”

4) The advantages of ATE with regards to medical negligence?

LM: “Put simply, without ATE funding it is unlikely that 90% of cases would be pursued.”

FC: “Where ATE insurance comes into its own with clinical negligence is by offering day one cover, thereby supporting the crucial investigation stage. With clinical negligence cases, a high proportion of fees are incurred at the outset while liability and causation are investigated, and these can be covered by the policy which provides everyone with peace of mind.

“And with partial recovery of the premium in these cases, insurers have the option to adopt a different approach to pricing which can result in a more favourable outcome for the claimant.

5) ‘The First 100 Years’ anniversary of women in law is a real landmark. But what still needs to change?

LM: “Enormous progress has been made by women in the law. However, more needs to be done in respect of flexible working so women are able to have a good work-life balance and pursue a successful career as well as having a family.

“Equally, flexible working and childcare is not an issue solely relevant to women – men should also be encouraged to work in a way which allows them to contribute more to family life.”

FC: “I have definitely noticed female legal leaders becoming more visible in the media. Nevertheless, I feel we need to see even more if we are to get a fairer gender balance in the industry. Seeing these images and reading these articles challenges bias, and seeing the success of females not only acts as an inspiration, but challenges stereotypes, and that’s really important.

“And while we’re on the subject, we certainly mustn’t forget ‘The First 100 Years’, a history project charting the journey of women in the profession since 1919. Their project is intended to celebrate, inform and inspire future generations of women in the profession – you can find out more at the First Hundred Years website.

“Here’s to the next hundred years!”

Heading to the ACNC this year? Arrange a meeting with one of our ATE team:

Contact us

AvMA 2019: The Evolution of ATE

With the AvMA Annual Clinical Negligence Conference (ACNC) taking place in Leeds this week, Robyn Lampon from DAS UK Group looks at how ATE insurance has evolved over the last 20 years.

June 2019 Learn more
Fixed recoverable costs in clinical negligence claims: the prog rock of consultations

Two years on the government’s consultation on fixed recoverable costs, ATE Underwriting Manager David Brown restates the DAS position on this highly complex issue.

April 2019 Learn more
SCIL 2019: A meeting of minds

Fran Clothier, DAS UK Group’s ATE Business Partnership Manager, shares her thoughts on the thought provoking annual SCIL (Society of Clinical Injury Lawyers) conference which took place in Birmingham recently.

April 2019 Learn more

Read more from DAS

ATE Dispute resolution through the eyes of an ATE provider

Dispute Resolution (DR) has been a factor throughout our 22 years of providing ATE insurance.

April 2024
ATE Resolving healthcare disputes with sensitivity and efficiency

Ian Long from Browne Jacobson talks about the importance of approaching clinical negligence disputes with sensitivity and empathy.

April 2024
ATE Using mediation in clinical negligence cases

Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) in clinical negligence claims can take many forms, including mediation. Anna Sari from Morrish Solicitors explains.

April 2024
ATE What we have learned from 7 years of mediation

Paul Balen from Trust Mediation reflects on what he has found from his time working under the NHS Resolution Mediation Scheme.

April 2024
ATE The evolution of ATE

Nathan Holt, Head of ATE & BTE Underwriting at DAS, provides his unique view on an everchanging legal landscape and ATE’s role in providing access to justice.

December 2023
ATE 1,100 and counting – the rise of dispute resolution

Mediation and dispute resolution are on the rise, and are increasingly being preferred over court. Paul Balen, Director at Trust Mediation and Trust Arbitration, tells us more.

December 2023
ATE Fixed Recoverable Costs: is Jackson “finished”?

Nick McDonnell, Director at Kain Knight, looks at the Jackson reforms and what work remains to be done.

December 2023
ATE Looking back on 2023 & looking ahead to 2024 in ATE

Henrietta Hughes, Barrister at 3PB, looks back at developments in the road traffic and personal injury arena.

December 2023
ATE Empowering smaller legal practices: The success of the Optimise scheme

The Optimise scheme, launched by DAS and Maxima, has supported over 100 clients over the past two years, transforming the landscape for clinical negligence and personal injury cases.

October 2023
ATE The pros and cons of a Low Damages FRC (LD FRC) process in clinical negligence

Lisa O’Dwyer from Action against Medical Accidents looks at how the LDFRC process will affect Clinical Negligence claims.

September 2023
ATE Fixed Recoverable Costs is upon us

William Ellerton, Partner at DAS Law, gives his predictions for how the new FRC could play out.

September 2023
ATE How QOCS changes have affected a law firm

Matthew Olner, solicitor at Nelsons, talks about how the QOCS changes have affected his law firm.

June 2023
ATE QOCS changes: The ATE Provider’s Perspective

In this article, Rebecca Squires and Jane Marigold from DAS give their perspective on the QOCS changes.

June 2023