West & Demouilpied – What now for the ATE market?

22nd August 2019
David Brown

David Brown

DAS UK Group

Underwriting Manager, ATE

In the recent Court of Appeal decision of West & Demouilpied, the court addressed the issues of reasonableness and proportionality, and the ‘proper’ approach to the assessment of costs – including ATE premiums.

It was a potentially huge moment for the ATE market, so I thought it might be useful to share my thoughts on the outcome, and break it down to its key elements; Demouilpied for Dummies, if you like.

The Background

Significantly, this was the first time an ATE premium had been scrutinised by the higher courts since Rogers v Merthyr Tydfil CBC in 2006. And whilst the decisions in West & Demouilpied focused on ARAG’s underwriting methodology, given the direct involvement of both DAS and LAMP in the Assessor’s hearing prior to the Appeal, this decision was always going to have wider ramifications for the market – and of course for the NHS.

It was anticipated that the decision would provide lower courts with much needed guidance on how to deal with the future assessment of ATE premiums in the post LASPO costs landscape.

The Decision

The bottom line is that ARAG was successful in recovering the ATE premiums associated with these cases in full, and there are a number of useful points to highlight that I think will assist the ATE market at large. The court:

  • Agreed that it is unacceptable for lower courts to make ad hoc, case-by-case decisions on cases if the premium has been block-rated;
  • Maintained that defendants cannot argue a premium is unreasonable by relying on photocopies of competitor premiums; expert evidence is required;
  • Conceded that they lacked the expertise to address whether a premium is reasonable, and to make that decision would put the whole market at risk;
  • Made it clear that block rated premiums – commonplace within the ATE market – cannot be reduced by referencing the value of the claim on a case by case basis; and
  • Acknowledged that if claimants are truly to be granted access to justice, then the continued existence of an ATE market to support this type of claim is of paramount importance.

The Impact

The impact of the decision remains to be seen, but here is what I think we can expect to see:

  • Greater certainty around how courts should approach premiums in the future, since judges in lower courts must have regard to this decision now;
  • Quicker resolution of costs and premium on future won cases;
  • The ATE industry having greater confidence around underwriting decisions in the future; and
  • Insurers who have considerable amounts of won but unpaid premiums now taking steps to encourage settlement of these premiums.

Whichever way you look at it, this will all be good news for access to justice, and a sustainable ATE market.

AvMA 2019: Women in law talk ATE

To mark the centenary of the Sex Disqualification (Removal) Act 1919, we got some female perspectives on ATE insurance and the role it plays in supporting access to justice.

June 2019 Learn more
AvMA 2019: The Evolution of ATE

With the AvMA Annual Clinical Negligence Conference (ACNC) taking place in Leeds this week, Robyn Lampon from DAS UK Group looks at how ATE insurance has evolved over the last 20 years.

June 2019 Learn more
A golden opportunity for ATE to innovate

Enrique Gomez, Head of ATE at DAS UK Group, looks at how the time is right for innovation in the ATE sector.

July 2018 Learn more

Read more from DAS

LEI news insights , Events , 2022 BIBA 2022 – Why your client might benefit from ATE insurance

We share two case studies highlighting the benefits of ATE insurance.

May 2022
LEI news insights , Events , 2022 BIBA 2022: DAS to showcase legal services designed to provide immediate value

DAS has announced that it will be showcasing a suite of legal risk-mitigation product extensions at this year’s British Insurance Brokers' Association (BIBA).

April 2022
LEI news insights , ATE , 2022 The importance of ATE to commercial LEI customers

Carol Parsons, Head of ATE at DAS, explains the difference between After the Event and Before the Event Legal Expenses Insurance.

April 2022
Products , ATE , 2021 DAS UK partners with Maxima to launch new Clinical Negligence & Personal Injury scheme

DAS and Maxima have launched ‘Optimise’, a new clinical negligence/personal injury scheme aimed specifically at smaller legal practices.

June 2021
Products , ATE , 2021 DAS and Pattinson & Brewer announce ATE Clinical Negligence partnership

DAS and Pattinson & Brewer have announced a new partnership to provide a bespoke clinical negligence product for the practice’s clients.

May 2021
Products , ATE , 2021 DAS chosen by Smith Partnership for clinical negligence product

DAS has been chosen by Smith Partnership to provide a bespoke clinical negligence product for the practice’s clients.

May 2021
ATE , 2020 MIB v Lewis: A Legal Landmark

Rebecca Squires, ATE Technical Supervisor, DAS UK Group looks at the landmark MIB v Lewis case. DAS UK provided Thompsons Solicitors, which acted for the claimant, with its ATE Personal Injury product to help fund the case…

August 2020
LEI news insights , ATE , 2020 We can all do more to help clients and customers

Alison Whitcombe, Propositions Manager at DAS, looks at how the ATE industry can do more to help clients and customers.

August 2020
LEI news insights , 2020 ABC v St George’s Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust: The Repercussions for Clinical Negligence

Jane Harper, ATE Technician, DAS UK Group looks at the ABC v St George’s Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust case which will have huge repercussions for clinical negligence.

July 2020
LEI news insights , 2020 LEI: the UK’s most important insurance cover?

Legal expenses insurance has a major part to play in giving people and SMEs everyday peace of mind, now more than ever before.

June 2020
LEI news insights , ATE , 2020 2020: Predictions for ATE and law

2019 was another interesting year across the clinical negligence, civil litigation and personal injury sectors. We asked some of our ATE team and solicitor partners what their predictions are for 2020…

January 2020
2019 2019: What are you doing for Christmas?

We asked some of our ATE team and solicitor partners how they will be spending their respective Christmases.

December 2019
LEI news insights , 2019 , ATE 2019: Achievements, fears and tech in law and ATE

We asked some of our ATE team and solicitor partners what their achievements were, what their fears are, and what they thought of the latest technological developments.

December 2019