Fixed Recoverable Costs – a Costs Lawyer’s view

2nd October 2023
Adam GrantAdam Grant

Costs Lawyer

KE Costs

We are on the verge of the biggest shake-up of civil litigation costs since 2013. 107 pages of additional rules will come into force which will absolutely transform the landscape in which parties recover their costs. These changes are as profound as they are wide-ranging – they do away with costs budgeting, the indemnity principle and most detailed assessments, and cover the vast majority of cases worth up to £100,000.00.  This is not an exercise in merely tweaking the rules.

The Intermediate Track

All cases on the Fast Track, with a very small number of exemptions, will be covered by a table of fixed costs, which vary based upon how far the litigation progresses and the complexity of the case. There is some precedent with fixed costs for cases worth less than £25,000.00; PI practitioners will be familiar with the tables within the current CPR r45.29.

The massive change is with the introduction of a new Intermediate Track, bringing a complex, yet uncertain fixed costs system to a huge number of cases, with significant quantum values and a wide diversity in respect of complexity.

A lack of clarity

There are a few notable fixed exemptions to the new rules, such as housing disrepair cases on the Fast Track or asbestos-based diseases on the new Intermediate Track. But clarity is not a recurring theme in the new rules, with their emphasis on judicial discretion.

Take allocation. The new track should only be for cases which require no longer than three days for trial and oral expert evidence from no more than two experts per party. The cynic may foresee claimants seeking oral evidence from 3+ experts and a four-day trial on every case, and defendants maintaining that two experts and two days will be sufficient on the most complex of cases.

The initial CMC will be a major battleground, and the implications in money terms of allocation and banding decisions will be immense. There will undoubtably be expensive mistakes made in the early days of the new regime.

How the changes will play out

This uncertainty will be a recurring theme in the work of Costs Lawyers over the coming months and years.  It will mean that we Costs Lawyers are more involved in your cases earlier on. The rules are complex, and we will be expected to understand not just the rules themselves, but how the judiciary are interpreting them – the current guidance is not great. We will be working tactically to ensure that if a case is subject to fixed costs, we obtain the highest banding possible, the cash differences between even adjacent bands is significant.

But the biggest expansion in a Costs Lawyer’s practice will be on the solicitor/client front. Having ‘wargamed’ some of the figures on recent cases I have been instructed on (and their likely fixed costs award had they been operating in the new regime), the shortfall between costs actually incurred and recovered will be stark.

It is almost unavoidable, in my opinion, that solicitors will be compelled to seek larger and larger contributions from their own client to make up this shortfall. It will be simply become uneconomical to run these cases without something plugging the gap.

It will be of paramount importance that your retainers with your clients are kept up-to-date and are watertight, as is your client billing process. Fall foul of the rules in this arena and an expensive, nasty solicitor/client assessment may be the result.

So my advice in a nutshell; work closely with your Costs Lawyer and keep your seatbelt on – there will be turbulence!

Will the extension of Fixed Recoverable Costs have any real impact on the CN sector?

Ian Cohen, from the Cohen Consultancy looks at how the extension of Fixed Recoverable Costs will affect the Clinical Negligence sector.

October 2023 Learn more
The pros and cons of a Low Damages FRC (LD FRC) process in clinical negligence

Lisa O’Dwyer from Action against Medical Accidents looks at how the LDFRC process will affect Clinical Negligence claims.

September 2023 Learn more
Fixed Recoverable Costs is upon us

William Ellerton, Partner at DAS Law, gives his predictions for how the new FRC could play out.

September 2023 Learn more

Share this:

Read more from DAS

ATE , 2023 Empowering smaller legal practices: The success of the Optimise scheme

The Optimise scheme, launched by DAS and Maxima, has supported over 100 clients over the past two years, transforming the landscape for clinical negligence and personal injury cases.

October 2023
ATE , 2023 The pros and cons of a Low Damages FRC (LD FRC) process in clinical negligence

Lisa O’Dwyer from Action against Medical Accidents looks at how the LDFRC process will affect Clinical Negligence claims.

September 2023
ATE , 2023 Fixed Recoverable Costs is upon us

William Ellerton, Partner at DAS Law, gives his predictions for how the new FRC could play out.

September 2023
2023 ARAG SE acquires D.A.S. UK

The ARAG Group and ERGO Versicherung AG, ERGO Group’s property & casualty insurer in Germany, have signed an agreement regarding the acquisition of D.A.S. UK, ERGO’s legal protection insurance business in the United Kingdom.

July 2023
ATE , 2023 How QOCS changes have affected a law firm

Matthew Olner, solicitor at Nelsons, talks about how the QOCS changes have affected his law firm.

June 2023
ATE , 2023 QOCS changes: The ATE Provider’s Perspective

In this article, Rebecca Squires and Jane Marigold from DAS give their perspective on the QOCS changes.

June 2023
ATE , 2023 QOCS – Two months on: A Barrister’s View

The full impact of the QOCS changes will be played out in years rather than months. Here, Henry King from 12 King’s Bench addresses what might be done about it from a claimant perspective.

June 2023
ATE , 2023 The impact of QOCS on costs lawyers

Change has long been brewing in relation to the Qualified One-Way Costs Shifting (QOCS) regime.

June 2023
Events , ATE , 2023 Rising to the Challenge: How ATE can benefit you and your customers

Carol Parsons, Head of ATE at DAS, talks about ATE and its numerous strengths ahead of BIBA 2023.

May 2023
LEI news insights , Events , 2023 DAS Powering Partnerships: How understanding legal risks can help you connect with customers

Ahead of BIBA 2023, here's a look at what we have to offer to customers, particularly in uncertain times.

April 2023
LEI news insights , ATE , 2022 ATE – The introduction of Qualified One-Way Costs Shifting (QOCS)

Since the introduction of QOCS and the subsequent change to ATE premiums being payable by the client, solicitors have faced some challenges when the client is a minor.

July 2022
LEI news insights , ATE , 2022 The importance of ATE to commercial LEI customers

Carol Parsons, Head of ATE at DAS, explains the difference between After the Event and Before the Event Legal Expenses Insurance.

April 2022
Products , ATE , 2021 DAS UK partners with Maxima to launch new Clinical Negligence & Personal Injury scheme

DAS and Maxima have launched ‘Optimise’, a new clinical negligence/personal injury scheme aimed specifically at smaller legal practices.

June 2021